Saturday, March 30, 2013

Week 4(?) - Scriabin: Piano Preludes part II

I'm back! I know it's not really week 4 anymore but as I'm still planning to do 52 weeks worth of listening I've decided to keep the numbering going, I'll just have to go a little over an actual year.

I just listened to eight different pianists play the Op.74 preludes. There are five preludes in all, of short duration and without a key designation. The whole set lasts about seven and a half minutes. Hear are Scriabin's descriptors: I. Douloureux, déchirant (Pain, tearing) II. Very Slow, contemplative III. Allegro drammatico IV. Slow, vague, undecided V. Fier, belliqueux (Proud, warlike). I really can't do better in describing this music. It is music that pushes and pulls violently, that floats unanchored, that does not resolve or if it does, it does so uncomfortably. What a change in Scriabin's harmonic language from his early preludes! There are hints of this coming change in some of the earlier preludes but there are only two opuses of the preludes that don't designate a key; Op.67 and Op. 74.

The pianists I listened to were Chitose Okashiro, Lucille Chung, Emil Gilels, Evgeny Zarafiants, John Ogdon, Maria Lettberg, Roger Woodward and Vladimir Feltsman. As always, it is fascinating to hear different interpretations. I think for this music to really work and ignite the pianist must have a freedom of rhythm and be willing to push and pull and pause more so than he or she might do in another composers music. Gilels and Okashiro excel at this. Their rhythmic freedom plus wonderful voicing really make this music come alive. Of all the pianists they are my favorites. Odgon and Lettberg are also very fine. Chung's playing is too square for me and Zarafiants takes an approach more toward the middle. I found Feltsman rather unimaginative. This leaves Woodard, who I found perverse! His playing is clunky, with no feeling of the mystery, heat and passion that Okashiro and Gilels bring to the music. 

I did listen to all the preludes and some of the highlights from that listening, weeks ago, were Kissin playing Op.15, Olli Mustonen playing Op. 16, and Okashiro playing Op.37, 39 & Op.59 No.2.

Saturday, March 9, 2013

Week 4 - Scriabin: Piano Preludes part I

What a modern miracle is technology! Sitting in my car outside a public library with my laptop connected to their Wi-Fi I just finished listening, on Spotify, to Mikhail Pletnev playing the 24 Preludes Op. 11 (1888 - 1896) of Alexander Scriabin (1872 - 1915) . What exquisite miniatures these are! They follow the same key structure as Chopin's 24 preludes (major key, then relative minor, then around the circle of fifths) but by and large are much shorter in duration. Whereas some of Chopin's preludes can stand on their own as individual works I felt that these preludes could not, and needed to be played as a group to be really appreciated. They are like 24 superlative pencil sketches that taken as a whole make up a wonderful work of art. While listening I was struck by how close some of the preludes were to the world of Chopin and Schumann while others where akin to the impressionism of early Debussy, all the while throwing in the distinctive harmonies that identify the music as coming out of Russia.

Yesterday I listened to two other preludes, Op.2 No.2 in B Major, and Op.9 No.1 in C sharp minor for left hand. The Op.2 No.2 is short with a gentle character and would be a great mystery piece for a 'Who's the Composer' game; my money would be on a lot of people thinking it was Schumann: no hints of Russia to my ears. The beautiful left hand prelude gives the illusion of two hands being used as there are three distinct events happening throughout; a melodic line, chordal accompaniment and a bass line. The pianist for these two preludes was Evgeny Zafariants on Naxos.

I then began listening to the Op. 11 preludes, comparing Zafariant's recording to Pletnev's and very quickly realized that Pletnev's way of phrasing, using rubato, pedal use, and dynamic voicing made the music come alive in a way that Zafariant's more restrained accounts did not. I find it continually fascinating that the printed music can be realized so differently from artist to artist. I dipped into other pianists for the first 3 preludes; Arthur Pizzaro, Elena Kuschnerova, and Niklas Sivelov. Sivelov tempos were extreme: Pizzaro, who I've heard live and enjoyed, was too fragmented with the line of the first prelude; Kuschnerova's playing, on the other hand, is something I will give another listen to.

I plan on listening to the rest of the preludes (there are a lot!). He wrote them throughout his life and listening to them will reveal his musical evolution. 


Saturday, March 2, 2013

Week Three - Karlheinz Stockhausen: Stimmung, Part II

I just listened to the Singcircle version of Stockhausen's Stimmung, recorded on Hyperian records. First of all let me say that anyone interested in modern music should listen to this. It's an amazing work whether you like it or not. The virtuosity and stamina that the singers would need to perform this piece is immense, not to say anything of all the preparation needed individually and as a group.

My listening experience was varied; the first 20 minutes or so (the whole piece lasts about 1:05 in this version) I was totally focused and enjoying all the varied rhythmic phonetic patterns, words and 'magic names'. Then my attention started to wander. There are sections in the middle where only one note is sounding and the rhythmic variety is gone. I tried to refocus but was finding it difficult; after all the work is basically only one chord with not all the notes sounding all the time, though I need to say that there are a couple of sections were the chord is put aside and non-chord note(s) are sung. I would be curious to see what the 'model'(see previous blog) is for those sections. The last 15 to 20 minutes I was ready for the piece to end. There was a moment that I laughed out loud though; there is a model where the the words 'Thursday, Donnerstag and others are sung and then suddenly, after a short pause all the singers on their respective notes of the Bb 9 chord sing in rhythic unison the word 'Barbershop'. Of course a 9 chord being an instantly recognizable barbershop chord! So I laughed but ... still wanted the piece to end!

I will, of course, give Stimmung more listening, though probably not any time soon. There are certain compositions that might be called concept pieces or head pieces. In other words they don't arise from a kinetic/emotional/spiritual impulse of the composer but rather arise from a conceptual idea. Stimmung strikes me as being that kind of work. I know that distinction is not so cut and dried and I don't want to oversimplify (yes, I know that I am) but while listening my body and emotions were pretty quiet while my mind was at first interested and then not so interested.

Thanks for reading and as always would love to hear your thoughts about anything I write! Feel free to disagree!

Wednesday, February 27, 2013

Week Three - Karlheinz Stockhausen: Stimmung, Part I

Okay, I might have bit off more than I can chew. I have a busy week and Stimmung is a long piece, an hour or more, and each performance is different. I have two recordings: the Songcircle version and the Paul Hillier & Theatre of Voices version. I will try to get to both and perhaps also the Collegium vocale Köln version on YouTube! But first, a short explanation of how this piece is put together.

Stimmung = 'tuning', 'being in tune with', 


1. Six amplified singers. (SSATTB)
2. Only 6 notes throughout (Bb, F, Bb, D, Ab, C). A Bb 9 chord.
3. The Score consists of four elements, a ‘formal plan’, six pages of syllabic models, six pages of magic names, and a page of poetry.
4. The ‘formal plan’ maps out 51 sections of unfixed duration that specify which harmonic of the low B flat is to be sung.
5. Each section had a lead singer which the other singers, if singing, slowly get in sync with, at which time the next section begins.
6. Singers highlight certain harmonics of their note by following the model chosen.
7. The models are rhythmic phonetic patterns, sometimes with words (see below).
8. In 29 sections 'magic names', gods and goddesses from around the world, are called out.
9. The erotic love poems, by Stockhausen, are spoken at various times.

Here's an example of one of the syllabic model pages:


In Part 2 of this blog I will listen and give my reaction to all of this!! Until then, wish me listening luck!

Saturday, February 23, 2013

Week Two - Gerald Finzi: Dies Natalis

Dies Natalis is a challenge. Not because of the music which is quite good and inventive but because of the texts written by Thomas Treherne (1637? -1674). I feel that to really appreciate this piece one must live with the text for a while as one would with poetry. I have only read the text as I listened for the first time and feel that I need more time to linger over it, to absorb it senza the music and only then to listen again.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Now I'm ready!


1. Intrada - This is without voice and seems to me to be a preparation for the first poem to come in the next movement.  It shifts back and forth between being pensively lyrical and peacefully lyrical with a small climax about 3/4ths the way in. It's interesting that Finzi feels a need for this purely instrumental movement before coming to the fascinating and not always understandable prose and poetry of Traherne. Perhaps he is trying to shift the listeners state of consciousness to be more receptive to what is to come. There is no break between movements.

2. Rhapsody - There are some really stunning moments here. The text is three paragraphs from Traherne's Centuries of Meditations. It's not easy to understand who is speaking here. It begins with the line "Will you see the infancy of this sublime and celestial greatness?". The title, Dies Natalis, is Latin for "Natal Day" or "Day of Birth" but certainly, while much of it seems to be the voice of an infant, this is not only or even mostly coming from the perspective of a human infant. Consider this line, opening the second paragraph, "The corn was orient and immortal wheat, which never should be reaped nor was ever sown." Surely we are being addressed by a consciousness that, while being new to the world, is also paradoxically deeply ensconced in eternity; the last line of paragraph three; "Everything was at rest, free and immortal." Finzi's word painting is wonderful, and his setting of the first two lines of the second paragraph is magical, using long sustained chords to evoke the sense of being outside of time; "I thought it stood from everlasting to everlasting."

3. The Rapture - Here's the poem:

-->
Sweet Infancy!
O heavenly fire! O sacred Light!
How fair and bright!
How great am I
Whom the whole world doth magnify!

O heavenly Joy!
O great and sacred blessedness
Which I possess!
So great a joy
Who did into my arms convey?

From God above
Being sent, the gift doth me enflame,
To praise His Name.
The stars do move,
The sun doth shine, to show His Love.

O how divine
Am I! To all this sacred wealth
This life and health,
Who rais'd? Who mine
Did make the same! What hand divine!


This is an intensely joyful rapture, beginning with violins trilling excitedly then playing an burst of notes which lead back to the trill. The tenor comes in and the first stanza rings out with the strings moving things along with bass pizzacato and moving notes in the upper strings. The third stanza starts more reflectively but soon returns to the music of the first two stanzas. The really stunning moment happens after the third stanza when the orchestra builds and then stops unresolved for a moment of silence ... then resolves to a single note melting into a minor chord and the singer declaims "O how divine I am!" The last two lines are unaccompanied except for an abrupt, dramatic chord and then while "divine" is being held the strings enter with the same trill passage that began the movement. It all ends with a blazing major chord; arpeggios, then tremelos, then stuck all at once. Rapture indeed!

4. Wonder is a gentle, for the most part rather quiet, movement with lush string writing and long melodic lines. The poem has three stanzas but the music is through composed. In the poem there is very much the idea that all things are Divine. "How bright are all things here!" in the first stanza, and ending the poem, "I nothing in the world did know/But 'twas Divine." The musical climax is at the word "Divine", Finzi pointing out here, as he does elsewhere, the importance of this idea. The music is always flowing, shifting with interlocking lines and modulations, until the very end, taking this  listener on a beautiful journey of wonder.

5.  The Salutation

-->
These little limbs, these eyes and hands which here I find,
This panting heart wherewith my life begins;
Where have ye been? Behind what curtain were ye from me hid so long?
Where was, in what abyss, my new-made tongue?

When silent I, so many thousand, thousand years
Beneath the dust did in a chaos lie, how could I smiles, or tears,
Or lips, or hands, or eyes, or ears perceive?
Welcome, ye treasures which I now receive.

From dust I rise and out of nothing now awake,
These brighter regions which salute my eyes,
A gift from God I take, the earth, the seas, the light, the lofty skies,
The sun and stars are mine: if these I prize.

A stranger here, strange things doth meet, strange glory see,
Strange treasures lodged in this fair world appear,
Strange, all, and new to me: But that they mine should be who nothing was,
That strangest is of all; yet brought to pass.


There is a saying, I know not where it comes from, that God made the universe and especially humankind so that He/She could know himself/herself. This poem can be seen as fitting in with that idea. Who's talking in this poem? "When silent I, so many thousand, thousand years/Beneath the dust did in chaos lie," Who is this silent I that now is awakened in "These little limbs"? "From dust I rise and out of nothing now awake,". The poem gives no answer except to say that what is happening is Strange; strange that this 'silent I' should now perceive smiles, tears, lips, hands, or ears. We moderns all know that the stuff of our bodies were created in the stars. Could it be that Traherne intuited this in his own way; that the dust of stars becomes us? Really fascinating!
As for the music, it's wonderful. What more can I say? It's a beautiful, stately movement with a walking pizzicato bass throughout much of it. It is full of grace and ends simply and softly which seems to me to be the perfect ending to this marvelous work.

I listened to two recordings: James Gilchrist with the Bournemouth Symphony Orchestra, David Hill conductor: and Wilfred Brown with the English Chamber Orchestra, Christopher Finzi conductor. Both very fine.

Here's a couple of interesting links about the meaning of  Dies Natalis and of Treherne's writings in general.
http://www.operatoday.com/content/2012/11/finzi_dies_nata.php
http://www.mum.edu/msvs/trahernepart1.html

-->

Thursday, February 21, 2013

Week Two - Gerald Finzi: Now Let Us Garlands Bring

Gerald Finzi (1901 - 1956) is a composer I'm only marginally familiar with, having played a few of his chamber works and songs, so I'm really looking forward to getting to know more of his work.
First off, Let Us Garlands Bring: Five Shakespeare Songs Op. 18, for baritone and piano or baritone and strings. The two recordings I'm listening to is Stephen Varcoe and the City of London Sinfonia conducted by Richard Hickox and Roderick Williams partnered with pianist Iain Burnside.

1. Come Away, Death. A terribly beautiful setting; stately with muted melancholy. Both performances are very well done but what a difference tempo makes! Varcoe takes this faster, at 2:59, whereas Williams is at 3:30. The slower performance with piano seems to me to be much more effective in expressing the sadness and resignation of the text, plus there is a sense of intimacy that the string version misses. I do not have the score and would be very interested to know what Finzi marks for the tempo.

2. Who is Silvia? is a total change of character from the proceeding song; joyful and in love! Both performances convey the happiness and celebratory meaning of the text. Finzi's setting is imaginative, using syncopation and modulation to great effect. I especially enjoy that the piano/strings are full partners in expressing the text, no mere accompaniments here!

3. Fear No More the Heat o' the Sun is a profound setting of a profound text.

Fear no more the heat o' the sun,
        Nor the furious winter's rages;
Thou thy worldly task hast done,
        Home art done, and ta'en thy wages:
Golden lads and girls all must,
As chimney-sweepers, come to dust.

Fear no more the frown o' the great;
        Thou art past the tyrant's stroke;
Care no more to clothe and eat;
        To thee the reed is as the oak:
The Sceptre, Learning, Physic, must
All follow this, and come to dust.

Fear no more the lightning-flash,
Nor the'all-dreaded thunder-stone;
Fear not slander, censure rash;
Thou hast finished joy and moan:
All lovers young, all lovers must
Consign to thee, and come to dust.

No exorciser harm thee!
Nor no witchcraft charm thee!
Ghost unlaid forbear thee!
Nothing ill come near thee!
Quiet consummation have,
And renownèd by thy grave!

I have listened to this song now three times and have been brought to tears twice. Why just twice? Once again the choice of tempo is so important regarding the effect on the listener! Varcoe takes 4:19 while Williams takes 5:43! That's a huge difference! This time the Varcoe is the performance that I prefer. The music moves along in a slow triple meter but never loses it's forward momentum while the Williams plods along and is in danger of falling apart. It could be also that the strings, with their ability to sustain notes, serve to hold things together better than the decaying notes of the piano, but the choice of tempo here is the main factor. Regardless of all that, this is a great song which I find profoundly moving.

4. O Mistress Mine is fabulously set by Finzi. Starting off all merry and carefree, using detached notes for 'Trip no further pretty sweeting', but then listen to what he does for 'Journeys end in lovers' meeting/Every wise man's son doth know', slowing down, going to a minor V chord (usually would be major) on 'lovers' meeting' and then suspending the rhythmic flow for 'Every wise man's son doth know', in essence questioning musically the assumption of those two lines of text, like when a person says something but you know they mean something else. Then it's back to carefree for a few lines until 'What's to come is still unsure:' where some slightly menacing dissonances make an appearance. Finzi sets the last two lines 'Then come kiss me, sweet and twenty/Youth's a stuff will not endure' with the same music as the first verse, giving them an extra poignancy. In sum: A happy song with a twist or two of wistfullness. Both versions are beautifully done.

5. It was a Lover and His Lass is another wonderful setting. More keys changes than in the previous songs and, just as in O Mistress Mine, highlighting the importance of a line by slowing way down and setting it off from the others; 'How that life was but a flower'. Also you can hear 'When birds do sing, hey ding a ding a ding' in the strings/piano. 

So to sum up, though these songs were originally composed separately and were only later put together as a group to celebrate Vaughan Williams 70th birthday, I think they work wonderfully well together, juxtaposing as they do Death, Love and the fleetingness of Youth. I'm really looking forward to listening to more of Finzi's music. I only have today and tomorrow before week three starts (been busy!) but because of a major snowstorm outside I should have some time to listen to more! Now, you go listen too!!



Friday, February 15, 2013

Week One - Steve Reich: Various Works part I

Today's my last day for listening and commenting on works by Steve Reich. Fortunately I have the day off and am hoping to listen to 3 or 4 more pieces. I do feel a real sense of discovery; Reich's music is something I will return to again and again. Music for Mallets Instruments, Voices and Organ and Music for 18 Musicians are my favorites so far this week.

Today's Music.

1. Come Out - This is a seminal work of Reich's from 1966; a tape piece that uses the voice of Daniel Hamm, a participate in the Harlem Riot of 1964. Hamm says, "I had to, like, open the bruise up, and let some of the bruise blood come out to show them". Reich starts with the whole sentence then immediately shortens it to just "come out to show them". This is then manipulated, using two tracks, one track slightly faster than the other, to create a phasing effect. Reich later goes to 4 tracks and then 8 tracks by which time the original words are indistinguishable. There is a pitch and rhythm to the words that when repeated and manipulated do create a musical effect. Having said that, this isn't a work I'll be returning to except as an example to others of Reich's formative ideas.

2. Different Trains - Wow! I was not expecting this. What a great piece! Written in 1988 for string quartet and tape. The origin for the piece lay in Reich's observation that, though he spent the first years of World War II riding a train between divorced parents in New York and Los Angeles, if he had been in Europe, he would, as a Jew, have been riding a train to a concentration camp. It's in three sections:
  • America-Before the War
  • Europe-During the War
  • After the War
What really surprised me was the rate of change for the pulse and the tonality. Everything I've listened to previously of Reich's would have a very slow rate of change tonally and sometimes the pulse wouldn't change at all or just once or twice. But in Different Trains there are multiple changes in each movement. Reich uses, just as he does in WTC 9/11, interviews with people, then uses a part of a spoken phrase to create a melodic fragment. This may have something to do with the high (for Reich!) rate of change. Reich also uses the sound of train whistles throughout; they are tuned to whatever tonality is present at the moment. The second movement uses air raid sirens to chilling effect, rising and falling against the spoken words and ever present syncopations of the string quartet.
I will definitely be returning to Different Trains and sharing this great work with friends and students.

Look for part II of today's blog later!